20 research outputs found
Symmetric conformity functions make decision-making processes independent of the distribution of learning strategies
Two main procedures characterize the way in which social actors evaluate the
qualities of the options in decision-making processes: they either seek to
evaluate their intrinsic qualities (individual learners) or they rely on the
opinion of the others (social learners). For the latter, social experiments
have suggested that the mathematical form of the probability of adopting an
option, called the conformity function, is symmetric in the adoption rate.
However, the literature on decision making includes models where social
learners employ either symmetric and non-symmetric conformity functions. Here,
we generalize previous models and show analytically that when symmetric
conformity functions are considered, the form of the probability distribution
of the individual strategies (behaving as a social or an individual learner)
does not matter: only the expected value of this distribution influences the
determination of the steady state. Moreover, we show that a dynamics that
considers strategies as idiosyncratic properties of the agents and another that
allows them to change in time lead to the same result in the case of symmetric
conformity functions, while the results differ in the case of non-symmetric
ones. This fact can inspire experiments that could shed light on the debate
about this point.Comment: 17 pages, 6 figures, links to the source code repositor
Statistical Physics Of Opinion Formation: is it a SPOOF?
We present a short review based on the nonlinear -voter model about
problems and methods raised within statistical physics of opinion formation
(SPOOF). We describe relations between models of opinion formation, developed
by physicists, and theoretical models of social response, known in social
psychology. We draw attention to issues that are interesting for social
psychologists and physicists. We show examples of studies directly inspired by
social psychology like: "independence vs. anticonformity" or "personality vs.
situation". We summarize the results that have been already obtained and point
out what else can be done, also with respect to other models in SPOOF. Finally,
we demonstrate several analytical methods useful in SPOOF, such as the concept
of effective force and potential, Landau's approach to phase transitions, or
mean-field and pair approximations.Comment: 29 pages, 4 figures, new section 6 slightly extended, figures of
higher quality, corrected typos, extended references, other minor
improvements throughout the tex
Think then act or act then think?
We introduce a new agent-based model of opinion dynamics in which binary
opinions (yes/no) of each agent can be measured and described regarding both
pre- and post-influence at both of two levels, public and private, vis-\`a-vis
the influence source. The model combines ideas introduced within the -voter
model with noise, proposed by physicists, with the descriptive,
four-dimensional model of social response, formulated by social psychologists.
We investigate two versions of the same model that differ only by the updating
order: an opinion on the public level is updated before an opinion on the
private level or vice versa. We show how the results on the macroscopic scale
depend on this order. The main finding of this paper is that both models
produce the same outcome if one looks only at such a macroscopic variable as
the total number of the individuals with positive opinions. However, if also
the level of internal harmony (viz., dissonance) is measured, then significant,
qualitative differences are seen between these two versions of the model. All
results were obtained simultaneously within Monte Carlo simulations and
analytical calculations. We discuss the importance of our studies and findings
from three points of view: the theory of phase transitions, agent-based
modeling of social systems, and social psychology.Comment: 24 pages, 5 figures, corrected typos and the algorithm description,
extended Methods and results section, replaced Fig. 1., added supporting
materials with derivations, layout issues solve